UNEP logo Ecotourism in the Wider Caribbean Region: An Assessment

Report Contents
Report in Word Format

CEP Technical Report No. 31 1994 All CEP Technical Reports

V. References

1. 1.Anderson, Susan (editor). New Investment and Development Opportunities in Tourism - The National Park System and Ecotourism. Papers presented to the Second Workshop on National Parks in Jamaica, June 18-19, 1992. Stencil. Jamaica, 1992.

2. Arzola Betancourt, Ricardo. Nuevas tendencias del turismo. Stencil of a transcript of a lecture in the Dominican Republic. August. 1992.

3. Bermúdez A., Fernando. Evolución del Turismo en las Areas Silvestres - Período 1982-1991. Stencil, Servicio de Parques Nacionales, Ministerio de Recursos Naturales, Energía y Minas. Costa Rica, 1992.

4. Bermúdez A., Fernando y Yadira Mena (compilers). Parques nacionales de Costa Rica - 1992. Publication of the Servicio de Parques Nacionales, Ministerio de Recursos Naturales, Energía y Minas. Costa Rica, 1992.

5. Bonaire Marine Park. Cuadros estadísticos. Manuscript. Bonaire, 1992.

6. Bonaire Marine Park. Informaciones diversas. Information pamphlets. Bonaire, various years.

7. Bonaire Marine Park. Introduction of visitor fees - Background Paper. Stencil. Bonaire, 1991.

8. Bonaire Tourism Corporation. Tourism Statistics Reports. Stencil without title. Bonaire, 1992.

9. Bonaire Tourism Office. Structure Plan of Bonaire. Cited by the Bonaire Marine Park, 1991.

10. Boo, Elizabeth. Ecotourism: the potentials and pitfalls, World Wildlife Fund. USA, 1990.

11. Caribbean Tourism Organization. Eco-tourism - A CTO Market Guide. Stencil. Barbados. 1992.

12. Caribbean Tourism Organization. Papers presented at the Second Caribbean Conference on Ecotourism. Stencil. US Virgin Islands, 1992.

13. Caribbean Tourism Organization. First Caribbean Conference on Ecotourism, Belize July 9-12, 1991 - Recommendations. Stencil. 1991.

14. Ceballos Lascurain, Hector. Estudio de prefactibilidad socioeconómica del turismo ecológico y anteproyecto

arquitectónico y urbanístico del Centro de Turismo Ecológico de Sian Ka'an, Quintana Roo. Mexico, 1987. (Cited by Elizabeth Boo, 1990).

15. Chacón Jiménez, Luis Manuel. Address of the Minister of Tourism of Costa Rica to the II International Symposium on Ecology, Tourism and Municipality. Stencil. Costa Rica, 1992.

16. Cifuentes, Miguel. Determinación de capacidad de carga turística en áreas protegidas. Technical Series, Informe técnico No.194, Centro Agronómico Tropical de Investigación y Enseñanza - CATIE. Costa Rica, 1992.

1.17. Dixon, John A. y Paul B. Sherman. Economics of Protected Areas - A New Look at Benefits and Costs Document of the East-West Center. Island Press. USA, 1990.

18. Ecotourism Council of the US Virgin Islands. Meeting Drafts. 1991 y 1992.

19. Governor's Economic Development Committee. The Overall Economic Development Plan for the United States Virgin Islands - Executive Summary Department of Economic Development and Agriculture). US Virgin Islands, 1992.

20. Holder, Jean S. Ecotourism - A fad or a way of life?. Paper presented to the First Caribbean Conference on Ecotourism. Belice, 1991.

21. Ingram, C. Denise y Patrick B. Durst. Nature Tourism as an Alternative Economic Opportunity for Wildlands Management and Rural Development: Marketing, Promotion, and Enterprise Development. Stencil without date.

22. Instituto Costarricense de Turismo. Anuario Estadístico de Turismo - 1991. Statistics from the Departament of Development, ICT. Costa Rica, 1992.

23. Instituto Costarricense de Turismo. Ley de Incentivos para el Desarrollo Turístico - No. 6990. Informative pamphlet. Costa Rica, 1992.

24. Linberg, Kreg. Policies for Maximizing Nature Tourism's Ecological and Economic Benefits. Working document of the World Resources Institute. USA, 1991.

25. Maynard, C.A.. A perspective on Caribbean Ecotourism. Paper presented to the First Caribbean Conference on Ecotourism. Belice, 1991.

26. McNeely, Jeffrey A., James W. Thorsell y Hector Ceballos-Lascurain. Guidelines: Development of National Parks and Protected Areas for Tourism, IUCN for WTO and UNEP. Programme Activity Centre on Industry and Environment, UNEP, UNEP technical reports series No.13. Joint Publication WTO/UNEP. 1992.

27. Ministry of Natural Resources, Energy and Mining of Costa Rica. Memoria Anual 1991-1992. Costa Rica, 1992a.

28. Ministry of Natural Resources, Energy and Mining of Costa Rica. MIRENEM. Newsletter, vol.1, year 1. Costa Rica, 1992b.

29. Ministry of Natural Resources, Energy and Mining of Costa Rica. Reglamento General para los Comités Regionales de las Areas de Conservación. Manuscript, Servicio Nacional de Parques. Costa Rica, 1992c.

30. Ministry of Natural Resources, Energy and Mining of Costa Rica. Sistema Nacional de Areas de Conservación - Un nuevo enfoque Report. Costa Rica, 1992d.

31. Norris, Ruth. Can Ecotourism Save Natural Areas?. National Parks publication, January/February, 1992. USA, 1992.

32. Reubold, Kalli y Tom van't Hof. Revitalisation of the Bonaire Marine Park. Report. Bonaire Marine Park. Bonaire, 1991.

33. Southworth, Sara T.. "Ecotourism case by case" in Travel World News, Monthly publication for travel agents. USA, May 1993.

34. Saint Thomas and Saint John Hotel Association. St.Thomas-St.John Vacation Handbook. U.S.V.I., 1993

35. Thelen, Kyran y Arne Dalfelt. Políticas para el manejo de áreas silvestres. Serie de Educación Ambiental No.1, Editorial Universidad Estatal a Distancia. 1979 Costa Rica.

36. Tourism Task Force. Tourism Task Force Report - United States Virgin Islands. Informe. Islas Vírgenes de EE.UU., 1991.

37. UNEP Regional Co-ordinating Unit. Caribbean Environment Programme. Relevant documents of the Protocol and Regional Programme on Specially Protected Areas and Wildlife in the Wider Caribbean Region. Jamaica, 1991 and 1992.

38. U.S.V.I. Department of Economic Development & Agriculture. Air Visitors. U.S. Virgin Islands 1989 Visitor Exit Survey. Summary Report. Prepared by the Bureau of Economic Research. U.S.V.I., 1990a.

39. U.S.V.I. Department of Economic Development & Agriculture. Cruise Survey. U.S. Virgin Islands 1989 Visitor Exit Survey. Summary Report. Prepared by the Bureau of Economic Research. U.S.V.I., 1990b.

40. U.S.V.I. Department of Economic Development & Agriculture. Hotel Occupancy Statistics. U.S. Virgin Islands - 1987 to 1990. Summary Report. Prepared by the Bureau of Economic Research. U.S.V.I., 1991.

41. U.S.V.I. Department of Economic Development & Agriculture. National Park Visitor Report - St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands. Bureau of Economic Research. U.S.V.I., 1993.

42. U.S.V.I. Department of Economic Development & Agriculture. U.S. Virgin Islands Annual Tourism Indicators. Statistics prepared by the Bureau of Economic Research. U.S.V.I., 1992.

43. Venezuela Tourism Corporation. Venezuela y el turismo ecológico. Stencil of the "Dirección del Situado y Equipamiento Turístico". 1992.

44. Whelan, Tensie (editor). Nature Tourism - Managing for the Environment. Island Press. Estados Unidos, 1991.

 

Suggested Reading

1. Forestry Private Enterprise Initiative. (FPEI). Several documents on ecotourism promotion by Durst, Laarman, Ingram & Wilson. For further information contact: FPEI, P.O.Box 12254, Research Triangle Park, NC 27709, USA.

2. Inter American Tourism Institute. The Institute has undertaken relevant research in ecotourism such as El motivo de compra del usuario turístico, Aplicación del marketing estratégico al turismo & Ecoturismo. For further information contact: Inter American Tourism Institute, P.O.Box 20043, Washington, D.C. 20043, USA.

3. McKinsey & Company jointly with the Nature Conservancy, the World Wildlife Fund and the Ford Foundation undertook a study on ecotourism between November 1991 and March 1992. The research involves Dominica, Jamaica, Puerto Rico and the US Virgin Islands. Deborah Arcoleo presented a summary of this research to the 2nd Caribbean Conference on Ecotourism (1992). For further information contact Mckinsey & Company, 55 E 52nd. Street, New York.

4. Miller, Marc L. y Jan Auyong, editors of the Proceedings of the 1990 Congress on Coastal and Marine Tourism - A Symposium and Workshop on Balancing Conservation and Economic Development, 2 vol. Event convened in Hawai, May 1990. National Coastal Resources Research & Development Institute, Newport, Oregon, USA.

5. Organization of the American States, Washington. The OAS has been working with tourism for a long time and has generated several reports relevant to the Wider Caribbean. Additionally, for the 1992-1993 period, has scheduled activities on international co-operation for tourism development as well as a number of multinational proyects in the following Caribbean: Antigua and Barbuda, Barbados, Dominica, Jamaica, St. Kitts y Nevis, St. Lucia, St. Vincent & the Grenadines, and Trinidad & Tobago

6. The PANOS Institute. Towards a Green Central America, published in 1993. 1717 Massachusetts Avenue, NW, Suite 301, Washington, D.C. 20036, USA.

Top of Page


ANNEX I.

 

Table 1: Macroeconomic impact of tourism, hotel capacity and annual visitor arrivals

 

Country/

Territory

Contribution by tourism

sector

Hotel capacity

 

GDP

Employment

F/X

Divi-

sion

Rooms

Occup. rates

All

incl. resorts

Number of Visitors

 

 

(%)

(%)

(%)

(No.)

(%)

(No.)

Annual

High Season

Antigua/Barbuda

60.0

NI

NI

NI

NI

7

193,584

85,774

Bahamas

55.0

60.0

75.0

12,800

55.0

5

3,600,000

1,600,000

Barbados

12.0

20.0

60.0

(c)

50.0

0

394,000

104,701

Belize

NI

NI

NI

2,913

NI

57

215,442

115,720

Colombia

1.5

(a)

(a)

43,072

55.8

0

856,000

NI

Costa Rica

7.5

2.5

25.0

13,075

50.0

(d)

580,346

377,225

Dominican Rep (b)

11.5

(b)

45.0

24,500

69.0

NI

100,000

60,000

Guyana

15.0

NI

NI

1050

40.0

10

NI

NI

Martinique

5.0

4.2

NI

6,600

55.0

(g)

751,000

409,000

Mexico

3.0

NI

35.0

150,376

54.4

(e)

(e)

NI

St. Vincent/Gren.

4.6

10.0

NI

1,109

NI

0

155,000

97,000

Suriname

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

NI

Turks & Caicos

50.0

25.0

NI

1,125

50.0

1

56,000

NI

Venezuela

13.1

21.3

NI

28,271

67.7

NI

598,328

244,444

 

NI No information

(a) 130,000 directly employed; US$440 million in foreign exchange earnings

(b) 50,000 directly employed; US$1,200 million in foreign exchange earnings

(c) 11,700 beds

(d) 192 tourist resorts; 10% all-inclusive

(e) Figures illegible on fax. Nevertheless, according to other sources, Mexico receives 5-6 million visitors annually.

(f) 50-60,000 visitors during high season and 30-40,000 during low season. These figures do not correspond with the annual total.

(g) 40% during high season and 23% during low season.

 

Table 2: Ecotourism: Concepts and definitions

Country/Territory

Concepts in use Definition
Antigua and Barbuda ---- No definition of concept given
Bahamas Ecotourism

The promotion of the territory's ecosystems and the increase in public awareness of the sensitivity of the natural environment, strengthening conservation efforts and the use of resources.

Barbados Ecotourism

Ecological tourism

Others

Hikes and other organized nature trips to botanical gardens, caves and other natural attractions

Belize Ecotourism

Controlled tourism, mindful of environmental damage, centered on nature and archaeological ruins.

Colombia Ecotourism

Ecological tourism

Type of tourism where the aim is to visit areas where nature has been kept relatively intact, in order to study, admire, observe and appreciate the flora, fauna and landscape as well as any other cultural expression. Small-scaled, controlled and managed educational/recreational activity.

Costa Rica Ecotourism

Ecological tourism

Commercialization of the concept of ecological tourism. Activity involving the enjoyment, study and conservation of a country's natural resources.

Dominican Republic Ecotourism

Alternative tourism

Ecological tourism

Adventure tourism

Developed in highly attractive natural and protected areas, producing immediate benefits, ensuring intelligent use of resources with tourism potential, in areas with few options for development, favouring some economic activity and encouraging conservation awareness.

Receptive.

At the local level bird watching, etc.

Horseback, riding, sailing, diving.

Table 2: Ecotourism: Concepts and definitions (Cont.d)

Country/Territory Concepts in use

Definition

Guyana Ecotourism

Alternative tourism

Emphasizes care in not altering any section of the ecosystem but provides economic benefits as incentives to conserving the environment.

Emphasis on culture and sports.

Martinique Ecotourism

Alternative tourism

Ecological tourism

Others

Visits to protected areas or areas of interest ecologically speaking and/or for its landscapes. Nature-related activities such as horseback riding, golf, etc.

Mexico Ecotourism

Activity in natural environment subject to guidelines on the preservation of nature and natural resources, generally accompanied by a practical application programme and/or environmental education.

St. Vincent and the

Grenadines

Ecotourism

Activity allowing the local population to generate income from their ecotourism resources while protecting them.

Suriname Ecotourism

Tourism in protected areas; bird watching

Turks and Caicos Ecotourism

Ecological tourism

No definition of concept given.

Venezuela Ecotourism

Ecological tourism

Excursions to natural areas in order to understand the cultural and natural history of the environment without altering the integrity of the ecosystem while providing economic opportunities for the local inhabitants thus making conservation work in their favour.


Table 3: Protected Terrestrial Areas

Country/

Territory

 

Current Situation

Proposal

 

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

 

Attractions

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

Attractions

 

No.

Surf. (Km2)

No.

Surf. (Km2)  

No.

Surf. (Km2)

No.

Surf. (Km2)  
Antigua and Barbuda

 

2

45

2

39

Natural

Cultural

Historical

1

6

1

NI

Natural
Bahamas

5

4,644

4

4,594

Flora/Fauna

12

NI

0

-

NI
Barbados

0

0

0

0

-

3

NI

NI

NI

Natural

Archeological

Belize

 

31

4,759

31

4,759

Archeological

Natural

13

192

13

192

Natural
Colombia

35

87,693

21

33,584

Natural

Archeological

Anthropological

0

-

0

-

-
 

Costa Rica

 

27

 

11,600

 

13

 

1,200

Natural

Geological

Beaches

Cultural

Historical

 

0

 

-

 

0

 

-

 

-

Table 3: Protected Terrestrial Areas (Cont.d)

Country/

Territory

 

Current Situation

Proposal

 

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

 

Attractions

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

Attractions

 

No.

Surf. (Km2)

No.

Surf. (Km2)  

No.

Surf. (Km2) No. Surf. (Km2)  
Dominican Republic

8

2,808

5

2,294

Natural

Scientific

Historical

4

NI

NI

NI

Natural

Scientific

Guyana

1

NI

NI

NI

Natural

Biodiversity

Exceptional

4

NI

NI

NI

-
Martinique

1

4

0

-

Natural

1

19

0

-

Natural
Mexico

71

67,661

6

32,861

Archeological

Natural

         
St. Vincent & Grenadines

0

-

-

-

-

2

NI

4

NI

Natural
Suriname

9

6,526

2

866

Natural

Cultural

Archeological

4

1,320

NI

NI

Natural
Turks and Caicos Islands

4

1

2

1

Natural

Archeological

Historical

0

-

-

-

-
Venezuela

202

633,487

38

73,440

Natural

Geological

Archaeological

Historical;

0

-

-

-

-

NI No information

 

Table 4: Coastal protected areas

 

Country/Territory

Current Situation

Proposal

 

Total area

Ecotourism Destination

Attractions

Total area

Ecotourism Destination

 

Attractions

  No. Surf. (km2) No. Surf. (km2)   No. Surf (km2) No. Surf. (km2)  
Antigua/Barbuda 1 0 0 0 0 Natural 0 0 0 0 0
Bahamas 2 7 2,869 4 2,869 Natural 45 3 NI 12-15 4 NI NI
Barbados 0 0 0 0 0 1 NI NI   Coastline lakes and dunes
Belize 5 884 5 884 Mangroves, fauna 5 0 5 0 Estuaries, valleys, rivers
Colombia 5 1,770 5 1,770 Mangroves, Coral reefs, Wetlands, Beaches, landscapes, Sites of archaeological, anthro-pological and cultural interest 0 0 0 0 0
Costa Rica 5 9 5,600 9 350 Coral reefs, Wetlands, Beaches, fauna 0 0 0 0 0
Dominican

Republic

 

6

 

1,397

 

5

 

NI

Coral reefs, Cays, Beaches, Wetlands, Caves, Fauna, Birds, Landscapes, Sites of archaeological, and scientific interest  

0

 

0

 

0

 

0

0
Guyana 0 0 0 0 0 1 NI NI NI Sea turtles
Martinique 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 Natural

Bird watching

 

 

Table 4: Coastal protected areas (Cont.d)

 

 

Country/Territory

 

Current Situation

Proposal

 

Total area

Ecotourism Destination

Attractions

Total area

Ecotourism Destination

 

Attractions

  No. Surf. (km2) No. Surf. (km2)   No. Surf. (km2)

No.

Surf. (km2)

 
Mexico

6

31,908

3

NI

Flora/fauna Migratory birds.Land-scapes Archaeological sites

0

0

0

0

0
St. Vincent & the Genadines

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0
Suriname

6

1,511

2

160

Migratory birds, Fauna, Sites of cultural and archaeological interest

1

1,900

NI

NI

Birdlife fauna
Turks and Caicos

24

693

3

2

Fauna, beaches, Excursions, Underwater sports, Cultural sites

0

0

0

0

0
Venezuela

28

31,000

10

4,321

Ecological diversity, Coastal formations, Flora/fauna

0

0

0

0

0

1 Antigua and Barbuda have provided, in a separate text, some useful information on the status of its protected areas and on areas being considered for protection. The information on coastal protected areas in illegible on the fax.

2 Includes both coastal and marine protected areas.

3 The Bahamas has provided, separately, information on the development of its system of national parks for which 52 area have been identified corresponding to different categories of conservation and covering an area of approximately 15,200 km2. These are predominantly marine and coastal areas.

4 Private property and commercial activities that are not formally integrated in an official promotional programme.

5 There are discrepancies in the case study figures.

6 Indicates a group of areas which have been recommended for protection.

 

Table 5: Marine protected areas

Country/

Territory

 

Current Situation

Proposal

 

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

 

 

Attractions

 

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

Attractions

 

No.

Surf. (Km2)

No.

Surf. (Km2)   No. Surf. (Km2) No. Surf. (Km2)  
Antigua and Barbuda

2

25

NI

NI

Natural

1

6

1

6

Natural

Cultural

Archeological

Bahamas (a)

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---
Barbados

1

NI

NI

NI

Fauna

Underwater sports

---

---

---

---

---
Belize

 

3

2

3

2

Underwater sports Birdwatching

Habitats, fishing

(b)

---

---

---

---
 

Colombia

 

2

 

687

 

2

 

687

Wetlands

Coral reefs

Coastal formations

Whales

Flora/Fauna

Primary forests

 

---

 

---

 

---

 

---

 

---

Costa Rica (c)

 

10

3,139

NI

NI

Coral reefs

Beaches, faunas

---

---

---

---

---
Dominican Republic (d)

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---
Guyana

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---
Martinique

---

---

---

---

---

1

1

---

---

Natural
Mexico

5

2,276

2

1,502

Coral reefs

Flora/fauna

Migratory birds

Landspaces

2

NI

NI

NI

Coral reefs
St. Vincent & Grenadines

---

---

---

---

---

1

NI

1

NI

Cays

 

Table 5: Marine protected areas (cont.)

 

Country/

Territory

 

Current Situation

Proposal

 

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

 

Attractions

Total Area

Ecotourism Destination

 

Attractions

 

No.

Surf. (Km2)

No.

Surf. (Km2)  

No.

Surf. (Km2) No. Surf. (Km2)  
Suriname

--

--

--

---

----

---

---

---

--

---
Turks & Caicos Islands

 

4

 

31

 

4

 

31

Underwater sports

Recreational fishing

Water sports

 

0

 

---

 

---

 

---

 

---

 

Venezuela

 

5

 

4,394

 

3

 

3,482

Mangroves

Flora/Fauna

Coral reefs

Submarine grasslands

Underwater sports

Recreation fishing

 

---

 

---

 

---

 

---

 

---

NI No information

(a) See corresponding note on the Bahamas at the end of Table 4.

(b) Several sites under study but as yet there are no formal plans to increase the number of marine protected areas.

(c) Number of wilderness areas administered by the National Parks Service with extension into marine areas.

(d) The response refers to the same areas indicated for coastal zones.

 

 

Table 6: Non-protected areas

Country/Territory

Land-Based

Coastal

Marine

 

No.

Visitors/yr

No.

Visitors/yr

No.

Visitors/yr

Antigua & Barbuda 1 --- 1 --- 4 ---
Bahamas (a) --- --- --- --- --- ---
Barbados 3 280,000 1 NI 0 ---
Belize (b) --- (b) --- (b) ---
Colombia NI NI NI NI NI NI
Costa Rica NI NI NI NI NI NI
Dominican Rep. 5 12,000 7 304,000 NI NI
Guyana NI NI NI NI NI NI
Martinique Many --- Many --- 0 ---
Mexico NI NI NI NI 1 NI
St. Vincent/Gren. 3 NI 1 NI 0 ---
Suriname 2 NI 1 NI 0 ---
Turks & Caicos NI NI NI NI NI NI
Venezuela 6 NI NI NI NI NI

NI No information

(a) The Bahamas states that figures were increasing at the time of the survey.

(b) Ecotourism activities are carried out in practically the entire country and it would be almost impossible to identify all the non-protected areas where these type of activities take place.

 

Table 7: Visitor arrivals

Country/Territory

Responses

Antigua and Barbuda The sites most frequently visited are Devil's Bridge (the most photographed, a rock formation), coral reefs (mostly visited by underwater tourism operators), etc.
Bahamas No information
Barbados No information
Belize No information
Colombia No information
Costa Rica 280,000 local tourists and 318,000 foreign tourists visited protected areas in 1992.
Dominican Republic Approximately 389,000 annual visitors to areas of interest, islands with clean beaches, cays, sectors with a high level of biodiversity and unique geological formations.
Guyana A number of sites, to which many tours are organized, have been designated tourist zones.
Martinique Most frequently visited site - ruins of Saint Pierre, patrimony of humanity, where a volcanic eruption caused 30,000 deaths in 1902.
Mexico No information
St. Vincent & the Grenadines Most frequently visited areas: Botanical Gardens (easy access), waterfalls (highly promoted) and cays (attractive to excursionists).
Suriname No information
Turks and Caicos Attractions generating a lot of interest: tropical rain forest, birdlife, monkeys, waterfalls and granite mountains.
Venezuela The most frequently visited areas are those geared towards ecotourism whose main attraction is the wildlife, especially birds.

 

 

 

Table 8: Legal and institutional aspects (Section VIII of the survey)

 

Country/

Territory

Organizations Involved in Ecotourism

Guidelines for tourism and the environment

Economic policy instruments affecting ecotourism or related activities

Antigua and Barbuda - National Park Authority - None - None
Bahamas - Bahamas National Trust

- Domestic Tourist Unit

- Ministry of Tourism

- Friends of the Environment

- Bahamas Chamber of Commerce

- None - No information
Barbados - National Conservation Commission

- Barbados National Trust

- Controls on coastal development

- Zonification of drinking water sources

- No information
Belize - Belize Tourist Industry

- Belize Tourist Board

- Ministry of Tourism and the Environment

- Ministry of Tourism and the Environment

- Declaration on Policy and Strategy

- No information
Colombia - INDERENA

- National Tourist Corporation

- National Tourist Board (Ministry of Development)

- Policies and directives on the development of ecotourism currently under study - None
Costa Rica - Ministry of Natural Resources and Mining

- Costa Rica Tourist Institute

- National Tourist Board

- Environment Code

- Law on Conservation areas

- None
Dominican Republic - National Parks Commission (Ecotourism Department)

- Ministry of Tourism

- ECOTURISA, Ecotourism Tour operators

- Ministry of Tourism Territorial Tourism Plan (1990) - not yet in force

- In the process of elaborating guidelines on protected areas (Ecotourism Department)

- No information
Guyana - Ministry of Trade, Tourism and Industry

- Tourism Association of Guyana, Ltd.

- Environment Policy

- Environment Protection Act (proposed)

- Financial incentives to promote tourism development

 

Table 8: Legal and institutional aspects (Cont.d)

Country/

Territory

Organizations Involved in Ecotourism

Guidelines for Tourism and the Environment

Economic Policy Instruments Affecting Ecotourism or related activities

Martinique -French Institutions - French Regulations Instruments

- General Law on Ecological Balance and Environmental Protection

- None
Mexico - Ministry of Tourism

- FONATUR

- Friends of Sian Ka'an, A.C.

- PRONATURA

- General Law on Ecological Balance and Environmental Protection - None
St. Vincent & the Grenadines - St. Vincent and the Grenadines National Trust

- Department of Tourism Group

- Forestry Division

- Forest Resource Conservation Act #47, 1992

- Wildlife Protection Act #16, 1987

- Import tax waivers on construction ma- terial and equipment and incentives for hotels
Suriname - Foundation for Nature Conservation (STINASU)

- Organization for the Exploitation of Tourist Areas (METS)

- Ministry of Transport, Communications and Tourism

- Suriname Airlines in collaboration with METS

- Law on Nature Conservation (creation and management of protected areas) None
Turks and Caicos Islands - Department of Environment, Heritage and Parks

- Tourist Department

- Fisheries Department

- PRIDE & National Trust (NGO)

- Legislation on National Parks, in force since 1992 None
Venezuela - MARNR (inparques)

- Corpoturismo

- Various NGOs; Audubon Asotucanes, BIOMA and Fundación Paria

- Plans for the management and regulations of national parks and areas of tourism interest

- Special regulations such as those on camps in the Amazons

- General Laws; Organic and Penal Laws on the Environment and the Tourism Law

None

 

Table 9: Planning

Country/ Territory

Development plans including environmental protection, tourism and ecotourism

Plans for the development of areas with ecotourism as an important component

Antigua and Barbuda

Spatial development project including

environmental protection formulated with support from UNEP

Development of the Island's Marine Reserve for Birds and the Wildlife Sanctuary in the context of the Parham Urban Development Project

Bahamas

There are plans; no details received

There are plans; no details received

Barbados

None

Network of protected areas in the process of development within the context of a growing national conservation strategy

Belize

No information

No information

Colombia

The Environment is gaining more importance in the planning process. Ecotourism has become an important aspect of the creation and management of protected areas.

A study is being done of protected areas where ecotourism can be vital for regional development

Costa Rica

Regional management plans. Initiatives by the Costa Rica Tourism Institute

In particular, the conservation plan for Guanacaste

Dominican Republic

Environmental protection is being considered, at the request of the Environmental Technical Commission, in tourism development, in management plans for parks, etc.

The development of areas devoted to ecotourism is being promoted by the private sector (Ecotourisa)

Guyana

No information

No information

Martinique

No information

No information

Mexico

The Director General's Office for Ecological Planning (SEDESOL) and the tourism and fisheries sectors, among others, are promoting ecological management projects in coastal and other regions possessing the potential for tourism activities in order to blend such activities into the natural environment

The development of ecotourism in certain areas has been promoted in some ecological management plans. (The case of the Bufadora region)

St. Vincent and the Grenadines

None

Studies have been done on the Caves in Tobago

Suriname

Management plans for some protected areas have been done and plans for others are being prepared

A natural reserve and a multiple-use area have been identified

Turks and Caicos

National Physical Development Plan; Insular Development Plan; Tourism Development Plan

None

Venezuela

Sustainable Plan for Tourism and Recreation in the Venezuelan Amazons; the Llanos Ecotourism Plan (to be implemented)

An environmental tourism centre is to be integrally planned for a rural area, a national park and an animal shelter

 

Table 10: Bases for the development of ecotourism

Priority Require-ments for the Sustainable Develop-ment of ecotourism 1/

National facilities and/or

experience for training

in ecotourism

Achievements and/or deficiencies

attributable to ecotourism at the national, regional and municipal levels

   

Achievements

Deficiencies

Antigua and Barbuda

With the exception of hotel facilities all other factors are in place (not in any order)

The facilities and the experience for training in ecotourism are not available but a future demand is foreseeable in this area. There are no plans in this respect

No information No information
Bahamas

Information

Legislation

Institutionalization

The facilities and the experience are not available for ecotourism but a future demand is foreseeable in this area. There are no plans in this respect.

No information No information
Barbados

Institutionalization

Legislation

Qualified personnel

No information

- Diversification of the Tourism Industry

- Appreciation of resource conservation

- Increased respect for the natural and cultural environments

- Risk of degradation through overload

Belize

No information

No information

No information No information
Colombia

Legislation

Incentives

Infrastructure

Qualified personnel

No capacity nor experience in training in ecotourism there is a demand for this and there are plans to address this

- Appreciation of the value of protected areas

- Information dissemination

- Generation of employment and economic benefits

- Poor efficiency in institutional tourism management

- Lack of adequate planning

Costa Rica

Infrastructure facilities

Qualified personnel;

Capacity and experience for training in ecotourism exist. A future demand for training in anticipated programmes are being planned to this end

None as yet None as yet. Measures are being hotel taken to avoid negative effects
Dominican Republic

Infrastructure

Economic Incentives

Hotel facilities

No information

No information No information

 

1/ The following factors were numbered 1-3 in order of priority:

Hotel facilities
Information Transport/Communication Legislation Equipment
Qualified staff Infrastructure Incentives Institutionalization

 

Table 10: Bases for the development of ecotourism (Contd.)

 

 

Priority Require-ments for the Sustainable develop-ment of ecotourism

National facilities and/or

experience for training

in ecotourism

Achievements and/or deficiencies

attributable to ecotourism at the national, regional and municipal levels

   

Achievements

Deficiencies

Guyana

Infrastructure

Transport/Communication

Hotel Facilities

No information No information No information
Martinique

No information

No information No information No information
Mexico

Infrastructure

Incentives

Institutionalization

No capacity nor experience for training in ecotourism. A future demand is anticipated and there are plans to address this

- Species protection (grey whale, queen butterfly)

- Development of support programmes for indigenous communities in protected areas

- Awareness of resource conservation

No evidence of this
St. Vincent & Gren.

Hotel facilities

Infrastructure

Transport/Communication

No capacity for nor experience in training in ecotourism but a future demand is anticipated and plans are underway to address this Generally well accepted Displacement of local community (case of the Tobago Cays)
Suriname

Institutionalization

Qualified staff

Transport/Communication

No information No information No information
Turks and Caicos

Infrastructure

Qualified staff

Legislation

Training - a need that can be satisfied through institutional workshops Only mentioned risks associated with tourism which is 100% ecotourism
Venezuela

Institutionalization

Information

Qualified staff

Capacity and experience in training in ecotourism. Future demand for training envisaged; there are plans to address this demand Only relative public and private interest in ecotourism development

- National Parks do not have sufficient funds to ensure proper service

- Inadequate permit-training procedure; lack of effective control

 

 

 

Table 11: Protected Wildlands in Costa Rica

 

 

Categories of protected wildlands Number Area (hec.)

National parks 18

- land areas 479,403

- marine areas 313,890

Biological reserves 7 17,653

National monuments 1 218

Forest reserves 9 303,385

Defence zones 28 159,873

Wildlife sanctuaries 8 125,583

National forests 1 900

 

Total 72 1,400,905

 

Source: Ministry of Natural Resources, Energy and Mines, 1992.

 

Table 12: International Tourist Arrival in Costa Rica according to zones and countries 1989-1991

Zones and Countries 1/

1989

1990

1991

Increment Period

 

No.

%

No.

%

No.

%

%

TOTAL

375,951

100

435,037

100

504,649

100

34.2

NORTH AMERICA

Canada

United States

Mexico

153,112

20,285

124,264

8,563

41

5

33

2

191,284

30,892

150,224

10,168

44

7

35

2

223,126

37,187

173,626

12,313

44

7

34

2

45.7

83.3

39.7

43.8

CENTRAL AMERICA

Guatemala

El Salvador

Honduras

Nicaragua

Panama

135,376

14,977

8,359

10,066

38,812

63,162

36

4

2

3

10

17

139,913

14,695

8,986

8,894

49,395

57,943

33

3

2

2

15

11

164,809

16,079

11,299

10,475

73,558

53,398

33

3

2

2

15

11

21.7

7.4

35.2

89.5

(15.5)

CARIBBEAN

Cuba

Dominican Republic

Jamaica

Trinidad and Tobago

Others

4,387

1,299

2,048

486

207

347

1

0

1

0

0

0

4,679

1,421

1,959

318

160

334

1

0

0

0

0

0

4,679

1,578

2,310

308

121

362

1

0

0

0

0

0

6.7

21.5

12.8

(36.6)

(41.5)

4.3

SOUTH AMERICA

Colombia

Venezuela

Argentina

Others

28,644

9,612

2,955

2,785

13,292

8

3

1

1

4

32,575

10,687

3,771

3,170

14,947

7

2

1

1

3

32,891

10,480

4,025

3,359

15,027

7

2

1

1

3

14.8

9.0

36.2

20.6

13.1

EUROPE

Spain

Germany

Netherlands

Italy

U.K.

France

Others

45,355

5,997

9,122

5,835

4,837

5,094

3,726

10,744

12

2

2

2

1

1

1

3

57,177

7,541

13,383

6,259

6,277

5,692

4,783

13,242

13

2

3

1

1

1

1

3

67,319

8,206

16,861

6,782

7,504

6,570

5,445

15,951

13

2

3

1

1

1

1

3

48.4

36.8

84.8

16.2

55.1

29.0

46.1

48.5

ASIA

Japan

China

Korea

Russia

Israel

Others

7,423

n/d

n/d

n/d

n/d

n/d

n/d

2

--

--

--

--

--

--

8,272

n/d

n/d

n/d

n/d

n/d

n/d

2

--

--

--

--

--

--

9,046

3,413

1,752

1,016

688

1,100

1,097

2

1

0

0

0

0

0

21.9

--

--

--

--

--

--

AFRICA

171

0

244

0

299

0

74.9

OTHER ZONES

1,483

0

1,380

0

2,480

0

67.2

N/D Data not available Source: Costa Rican Tourism Institute, 1992.

1/ Zones and groups of countries taken from source.

 

Table 13: International Tourist arrivals in Costa Rica according to zones, 1992-1991

Year

North America

Central America

Caribbean

South America

Europe

Other Zones

Total

1982

82,591

214,281

5,959

30,334

32,206

6,211

371,582

1983

84,762

173,844

7,425

23,112

31,740

5,259

326,142

1984

88,360

126,474

5,055

20,432

28,516

5,064

273,901

1985

89,825

112,623

4,294

20,915

28,179

5,716

261,552

1986

93,105

106,825

3,957

21,272

29,026

6,655

260,840

1987

104,841

108,543

3,438

21,768

32,354

6,917

277,861

1988

123,551

124,728

5,103

26,150

41,396

8,458

329,386

1989

153,112

135,376

4,387

28,644

45,355

9,077

375,951

1990

191,284

139,913

4,192

32,575

57,177

9,896

435,037

1991

223,126

164,809

4,679

32,891

67,319

11,825

504,649

 

Accumulative annual growth rate:

91/82 11.7 (2.9) (2.7) 0.9 8.5 7.4 3.5

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

86/82 3.0 (16.0) (9.7) (8.5) (2.6) 1.7 (8.5)

91/86 19.1 9.1 3.4 9.1 18.3 12.2 14.1

Source: Costa Rican Tourism Institute, 1992

 

Table 14: Tourism in Costa Rica and visits to National Parks

Year

 

Visits to National Parks

Total intl. tourist arr.

in Costa Rica 1/ (D)

Percentage Relation C/D

 

Total (A=B+C)

Nationals (B)

Foreigners (C)

   
 

(No.)

(No.)

%

(No.)

(%)

(No.)

(E=C/D*100)

1982

205,640

140,262

68.2

65,378

37.8

371,582

17.6

1983

194,402

134,136

69.0

60,266

31.0

326,142

18.5

1984

134,063

170,101

72.7

63,962

27.3

273,901

23.4

1985

245,662

182,161

74.2

63,501

25.8

261,552

24.3

1986

261,967

191,911

73.3

70,056

26.7

260,840

26.9

1987

287,047

215,324

75.0

71,723

25.0

277,861

25.8

1988

360,222

235,512

65.4

124,710

34.6

329,386

37.9

1989

394,742

228,206

57.8

166,536

42.2

375,951

44.3

1990

453,033

240,036

53.0

212,997

47.0

435,037

49.0

1991

496,406

222,975

44.9

273,431

55.1

504,649

54.2

 

 

Accumulative annual growth rate: 2/

91/82 10.3 5.3 17.2 3.5 13.3

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

86/82 6.2 8.2 1.7 (8.5) 11.2

91/86 13.6 3.0 31.3 14.1 15.1

1/ The data does not include stop-over tourists arriving on cruise ships.

2/ The rates calculated include only the extreme years of each series.

Source: National Parks' Services (MINEREM), 1992

Costa Rican Tourism Institute, 1992

 

 

Table 15: Tourist indications for the Virgin Islands 1980-1991

Year

Visitors (a)

(in thousands)

Expenditure

(millions US$)

Cruise Ships (b)

General Empl.

 

Total

Tourist

Excurs.

Total

Tourists

Excurs.

No.

No.

1983

1,213.7

345.0

868.7

356.3

263.1

93.2

715

6,890

1984

1,264.8

369.5

895.3

440.1

308.8

131.3

789

7,190

1985

1,315.5

411.6

903.9

507.4

365.4

142.0

790

7,620

1986

1,654.4

463.1

1,191.3

509.5

386.6

122.2

1109

8,390

1987

1,917.8

541.8

1,376.0

639.4

401.4

238.0

1242

9,580

1988

1,881.4

555.5

1,325.9

659.6

411.6

248.0

1121

9,800

1989

1,764.0

506.7

1,257.3

673.7

497.6

176.1

1106

9,320

1990

1,866.4

521.5

1,344.9

704.4

515.6

188.8

1142

8,640

1991

1,942.7

511.8

1,430.9

708.1

506.3

201.8

3240

8,830

Growth rate over the period (c):

Total 60.1 48.3 64.7 98.7 92.4 116.5 73.4 28.2

Annual 6.1 5.1 6.4 9.0 8.5 10.1 7.1 3.1

(a) Tourists and excursionists are those who stay more than 24 hours or less, respectively.

(b) Those docking at St. Thomas and/or St. John.

(c) The accumulative annual growth rate between the extreme years of a series.

Source: Economic and Agricultural Development Secretariat (1992)

 

 

Table 16: Main Hotel Statistics. 1987-1990

===============================================
Concept			1987	1988	1989	1990
===============================================

Rooms available:
-  Territory	        5,162	5,291	5,478	4,466
-  St. Thomas/St. John	3,686	3,848	4,026	3,286
-  St. John	       861	862	863	926

Night occupancy:
-  Territory	     1,206,540	1,225,713	1,095,910	933,832
-  St. Thomas/St. John	868,814	881,127	766,109	745,432

Number of guests:
-  Territory	578,296	699,77	634,004	471,868

Occupancy Level (%):
-  Territory	64.2	62.3	60.9	63.0
-  St. Thomas/St. John	65.1	62.1	59.8	62.3

Permanence:
-  Territory	5.0	5.0	5.4	4.5

===============================================


Source: Economic and Agricultural Development Secretariat, 1991.

 

 

Table 17: Visitor preference - 1989

Categories

Visitors arriving by air

Tourist cruise ship passengers

Beaches and sea

21.9

12.1

Climate

18.0

18.5

People

.9

11.3

Island tours

5.8

12.2

Diving

5.7

2.2

Relaxation

5.7

3.5

The island in general

4.8

5.5

Everything

4.0

7.8

Sport sailing

3.8

0.1

Shopping

3.1

16.6

Accommodation

2.6

0.1

Restaurants/meals

2.5

1.2

Visits to relatives/friends

2.4

0.1

Recreation

0.5

0.2

National parks

0.4

0.0

Bars and nightclubs

0.4

0.7

Fishing

0.2

0.0

Urban areas

0.1

0.5

Others

7.4

7.1

No preference

0.8

0.2

Adjustment

--

0.1

Total

100.00

9.9

Source: Economic and Agricultural Development Secretariat (1990a, 1990b)


Report Contents

Last Updated: